|
Notes on the brain: Does music
make you smarter?
ENRIQUE FERNANDEZ
Knight Ridder Newspapers
Parents
who play Mozart for a baby - or a pregnant belly - with the
long-range hope of a letter of acceptance to Harvard should
know their project is futile. On the other hand, exposing a
child to great music - as a listener and as a player - will
eventually pay off in increased smarts.
"Nothing activates as many areas of
the brain as music," researcher Donald A. Hodges recently
told an audience of University of Miami students and
faculty.
On the screen above him, Hodges
showed scans of the brain in the midst of musical activity.
Both hemispheres were lit up, in Hodges' words, "like a
pinball machine."
Hodges is Covington Distinguished
Professor of Music Education and director of the Music
Research Institute at the University of North Carolina at
Greensboro. He was on campus as part of the Stamps Family
Distinguished Visitors Series to share his findings on the
relation of music to the brain.
And to answer a question that has
been floating around both scholarly and popular culture for
a while: Does music make you smarter?
"The answer is 'no' in a
superficial sense," Hodges said. In 1993, experimenters
claimed that listening to a Mozart sonata would make your IQ
increase by eight points. Subsequent work, Hodges explained,
proved that such listening would sharpen a subject's
spatial-temporal relationships momentarily. After a short
while, the subject would go back to being just smart as
before. Or dumb.
But, he explained, a rich
environment makes a difference: "The brain: Use it or lose
it. The more education you have, the more the
interconnections in the brain. Music changes the brain."
Admitting that this research moves
at a slow pace - it is prohibitively expensive - Hodges
outlined some major findings:
• Disproving
earlier assumptions that musical activity takes place in the
right hemisphere of the brain, the activity occurs with
equal vigor in the left - or rational - hemisphere. Music is
an emotional and intellectual activity that engages all the
brain. Almost.
• During
performance, there is almost no activity in the frontal
lobe, where conscious thought takes place. When Yo-Yo Ma is
playing his cello in concert he's not thinking, Hodges
argued. All the thought took place earlier and if he were to
think now it would impede his playing. He is simply
performing, much like a highly trained athlete.
• "Music
is always a physical activity," Hodges said. "Musicians are
small-muscle athletes." And not just the performer. A
listener sitting still in a classical concert hall is having
the area of the brain that controls motion stimulated. Thus,
that convention - not moving during classical performances -
is unnatural.
Hodges learned how the brain reacts
to music by making musicians perform in the most difficult
conditions. Theresa Lesiuk, who teaches music therapy at
University of Miami, was one of Hodges' subjects when they
were both working in San Antonio. In her campus office, she
recalls the experiments.
"I had to lie down in a gurney with
an IV of radioactive material in me. They put a mask over my
face and I was blindfolded. Then my head was placed in a
tube."
And on a keyboard she had to play
Bach. A PET scan picked up the radioactive material and
showed which areas of the brain were activated. Images from
those scans were what Hodges showed at his University of
Miami lectures.
"We had to do this several times
and the IV tube kept getting caught as I played. 'Ow!' "
"We have to know what the brain is
doing," says Shannon de L'Etoile, who heads the music
therapy program at the University of Miami. "Hodges' work is
our bread and butter."
De L'Etoile explains that a person
with brain damage from a stroke may not be able to speak,
but can sing because the area that controls music is not
damaged. A therapist will get the patient to sing a phrase,
then change it to spoken language with an exaggerated
rhythm, and finally to natural language. "We are rerouting
through the healthy part of the brain," de L'Etoile
explains.
"The spinal chord reacts
immediately to rhythm," says de L'Etoile, who says that such
therapy can be used with Parkinson's patients.
And, researchers have learned that
autistic children are capable of reproducing patterns of
music, which a therapist can translate to language and to
unlock the social interactions autism prevents.
Lesiuk, whose work focuses more on
psychotherapy, is researching the high burnout rate of
computer system designers and how music can help. In
therapeutic situations, music can help a patient reflect on
the lyrics of a song or express their feelings. And not just
happy feelings - music can help unblock anger.
At University of Miami, Hodges had
said that "music makes you smarter because it helps you
understand yourself as a human being and your relationship
to the world." Echoing him, Lesiuk believes that "music can
help us unblock the search for our inner self."
Except that Hodges goes beyond the
individual search. Waiting at the University of Miami for a
ride to the airport and his next lecture destination, the
researcher explained how "like mathematics, music is a
necessary way of understanding the universe."
Dismissing notions that music is
just "ear candy," Hodges said that "the fetus has the ears
working already and a newborn can pick out the mother's
voice - for the baby, it is music."
Knight Ridder correspondent
Jacob Goldstein contributed to this report.
MEDICAL UPDATE
|